I honestly buy the CHEAPEST black eyeliner pencil I can find. Usually wet n wild is a great brand. TIP: to keep your eyeliner from smudging you need to apply a black eye shadow over it with an eye shadow applicator. It sets the liner so that it doesn...
Liquid eyeliners the only way to go. Black or brown.
I think one good place to start would be looking for the right eyeliner. I've heard of this one eyeliner from a brand named Bobbi Brown. It's applied with a brush like powder eyeliner would be, but it's more like a gel? It's kind of expensive, but I ...